| 2024 — Lee Coppola, '64 |
| 2023 — David Yaun, '85 |
| 2022 — Denise Doring VanBuren, '83 |
| 2021 — Danica Roem, '06 |
| 2020 — Charlie Specht, '10 |
| 2019 — Adrian Wojnarowski, '91 |
| 2015 — William Holzerland, Esq., '02 |
| 2014 — Steve Lingle, '10, and Jerry Lee, '11 |
| 2013 — Kristan McMahon, '97 |
| 2012 — John Hanchette, '64 |
| 2011 — Robert J. McCarthy, '76 |
| 2010 — Dan Herbeck, '78 |
| 2009 — Jeff D'Alessio, '91 |
| 2008 — Greg Mitchell, '70 |
| 2007 — Jim Aroune, '87 |
| 2006 — Michael Ryan, '77 |
| 2005 — Victoria Corderi, '79 |
| 2004 — Shaun Sheehan, '66 |
| 2003 — Daniel Collins, '73 |
| 2002 — John Krieger, '51 |
| 2001 — Edward Casey, '52 |
| 2000 — Gerard J. Monaghan, '67 |
| 1999 — Lisa A. Biedenbach, '76 |
| 1998 — Monica Nollet Roland, '68 |
| 1997 — Donna Rucci Collins, '79 |
| 1996 — Leslie M. Easton, '86 |
| 1995 — Christopher M. LaPlaca, '79 |
| 1994 — Daniel Barry, '80 |
| 1993 — Kathy M. Kozdemba, '75 |
| 1992 — Robert P. Carr Jr., '75 |
| 1991 — Carol Anne Schumacher, '78 |
| 1990 — Laurence J. McQuillan, '69 |
| 1989 — Janet Bodnar, '71 |
| 1988 — Charles J. Hanley, '68 |
| 1987 — Joette Riehle, '71 |
| 1986 — Jim Peppard, '69 |
| 1985 — Robert Dubill, '58 |
| 1984 — Kathleen Brady, '68, & Lawrence B. Sackett, '71 |
| 1983 — Allen Bruce, '63 |
| 1982 — Margaret "Peg" Breen, '68 |
| 1981 — Joan Roeben Licursi, '65 |